Research

Rent or buy a home? Twelve years of real numbers

“I pay €950 a month in rent. With a mortgage I would pay €670. Am I throwing money away?” To answer, we followed two people month by month, from December 2014 to October 2026, in Turin: Marco buys, Elena rents and invests. Same money at the start, same budget every month. This is the full method behind our video, with every assumption written out so you can change it.

Rent vs Buy in Italy — video

The video loads from YouTube only when you press play. Watch on YouTube.

Marco buys €94,500

Left in October 2026 after selling the flat, repaying the mortgage and paying the agency.

Elena rents and invests €150,000

Left in October 2026 after selling the fund and paying 26% tax on the gain.

Marco and Elena are invented; the prices, rents, rates and fund data are historical. A simulation on past data with stated assumptions, not a forecast and not advice.

1. The rules: same money, same budget, one fund

December 2014. A three-room flat of 85 m² between Borgo San Paolo and Pozzo Strada, a semi-central area of Turin, with an asking price of €1,977 per m²: about €168,000. Marco and Elena both start with the cash Marco needs to buy it, and they follow three rules.

Marco's start

ItemAmount
Price, 85 m² at €1,977/m²€168,045
Mortgage, 80% of the price, 30 years fixed at 3.9%€134,436
Down payment€33,609
Registry tax (2% of the cadastral value), mortgage and cadastral tax€1,832
Notary, purchase deed and mortgage deed€4,800
Agency, 3% + VAT€6,150
Bank: application fee, valuation, 0.25% substitute tax€1,686
Cash needed on the day€48,077

The monthly payment is €634. But a payment is not what owning costs: Marco also pays maintenance (1% of the value a year), the insurance the bank requires (€250 a year) and his share of extraordinary building works (€300 a year, a cautious assumption), and gets back 19% of the interest he pays, up to €4,000 of interest a year. Everything included, his home costs him about €755 a month. There is no IMU: a main home that is not a luxury property is exempt.

Elena's start

Elena signs a 4+4 contract at €8.0 per m², the Turin average in 2014: €680 a month. Under the flat-tax regime (cedolare secca) the rent cannot be indexed to inflation, so it stays fixed for eight years. She pays a deposit of three months (€2,040, returned at the end) and one month plus VAT to the agency (€830), and invests the remaining €45,200 on day one. Every month she spends less than Marco, she invests the difference too: about €50–110 a month in the first eight years.

2. Twelve years, month by month

Marco's wealth is the house minus the debt (plus the fund he starts buying in 2023); Elena's is her portfolio plus the deposit. Values at the start of each month, before selling anything.

Marco: house minus mortgage Elena: portfolio
047.87k95.73k143.6k191.47k 201520162017201820192020202120222023202420252026
047.87k95.73k143.6k191.47k 201520162017201820192020202120222023202420252026

3. Test one: Marco pays every month, and gets poorer

In the first years a mortgage payment is mostly interest. In 2015 Marco pays €7,600: €5,200 is interest and only €2,400 reduces the debt. Meanwhile asking prices in Turin fall about 20%, and his flat goes from €168,000 to about €135,000 at the start of 2019 — faster than he repays the debt. His wealth falls from €33,300 to about €11,200.

It does not feel like a loss, and for many people it is not the point. Marco has a fixed payment and a home he can plan to stay in, and the part of the payment that repays the debt works as forced saving: €35,500 over twelve years. That is one of the main reasons people buy, and it does not appear in any chart.

4. Test two: the 2020 crash, and 2022

On 19 February 2020 Elena's portfolio is worth €83,100. On 23 March it is worth €55,400: −33% in five weeks. She does not sell, and keeps investing her monthly difference. In 2022 it happens again, more slowly: from €110,600 at the start of the year to €94,400 in July, about −15%.

Writing the plan was easy. Most of Elena's result depends on the weeks when keeping it was hard: an investor who sold in March 2020 would not have this outcome.

5. Test three: the new rent

January 2023: after eight years Elena's contract ends, and rents in Turin have started to climb. We assume a new rent of €10.7 per m², between the €8.0 of 2019 and the €13.5 of 2026: €910 a month, 34% more. Marco's payment is still €634. Now living costs him less than her, and he starts investing the difference, about €160 a month, in the same fund.

This is the real advantage of a fixed-rate mortgage: a payment that does not move for thirty years while prices around it rise. And from 2019 Turin's house prices recovered, to about €2,250 per m² in October 2026: Marco's flat is worth about €191,000.

6. October 2026: what is left

MarcoElena
House value (€2,250/m²)€191,250—
Remaining mortgage−€98,928—
Fund€9,865€177,419
Rental deposit returned—€2,040
Before selling€102,187€179,459
Agency on the sale, 3% + VAT−€7,000—
26% tax on the fund's gain−€659−€29,432
Selling everything€94,528€150,027

In this simulation Elena ends with about €55,500 more. Marco sells his first home tax-free (he has lived in it for more than five years); Elena pays tax on twelve years of gains, and the figure above is already net of it.

Who was throwing money away?

Both of them. In twelve years Elena paid about €108,000 in rent and agency fees that she will never see again. Marco lost about €85,000: €54,500 of interest, €24,900 of owner's costs and €14,500 of buying costs, minus €9,000 of tax relief — and another €7,000 to the agency if he sells. The question is not who pays to have a home, because everyone does. It is who pays less, and what they do with the rest.

7. Change one assumption

The result depends on a handful of choices. These are the ones that move it most, each changed on its own and everything else kept the same.

Scenario, selling everything in October 2026MarcoElena
Base case€94,500€150,000
Marco refinances in July 2016 at a 2.2% fixed rate (payment €515)€113,100€141,000
Elena invests only the starting capital, never the monthly difference€94,500€136,300
Elena keeps everything in a current account at 0%€94,500€53,300
Extraordinary building works €600 a year instead of €300€93,100€155,300
Extraordinary building works €1,200 a year€90,100€165,900

Refinancing halves the gap but does not close it: a lower payment means Marco spends less, so Elena invests less and Marco more. The two lines in the middle are the important ones. Renting alone made nobody richer: with the same choices and the money left in a current account, Elena would have about €53,300, just over half of Marco. And most of her result comes from the €45,200 she invested on day one, which on their own became €136,300.

8. The honest part

Deep dive

What if nobody sells? Thirty years, to the last payment

The video stops after twelve years, when both of them sell. But Marco's mortgage lasts thirty: the last payment is in December 2044. What happens if both keep going, Marco in his flat and Elena renting and investing?

From November 2026 there is no real data any more, so the same monthly model continues on assumptions — the same for both, in four scenarios. These are not forecasts: they show which numbers decide the answer.

With each renewal the gap widens in Marco's favour. His home costs him about €800 a month in 2031 and €860–930 at the end, while Elena's rent jumps to €1,033 and then €1,211: Marco invests the difference, €200–400 a month. Elena keeps the head start of her first twelve years, and it keeps compounding.

December 2044, selling everythingMarcoElenaAhead
House 0% a year, fund 4% a year€269,100€281,100Elena +€12,000
House 0% a year, fund 7% a year€293,500€453,800Elena +€160,200
House 2% a year, fund 4% a year€340,400€281,100Marco +€59,200
House 2% a year, fund 7% a year€363,400€453,800Elena +€90,400

Over thirty years the winner depends on two numbers nobody knows in advance. With the house flat, Elena finishes ahead if her fund earns more than about 3.7% a year; if the house grows 2% a year, she needs more than about 5.4%. If Marco keeps the flat instead of selling it, he also saves the agency fee, €7,000–10,000.

And 2044 is not the end of the story. From 2045 Marco's home costs him only €225–295 a month in maintenance and insurance, while Elena still pays €1,211 of rent, and more at every renewal. To live the same way, her portfolio has to pay her rent: about €14,500 a year, for as long as she lives there. A paid-off home is income you no longer have to produce.

9. And today?

Elena's result describes those twelve years, not the next twelve. The starting point has changed: in 2014 that flat cost almost 21 years of rent, today about 17. In Turin rents are up about 69% since 2019, prices much less.

Back to the question at the top: €950 of rent against a €670 payment. Today the same flat costs about €191,000; an 80% mortgage of €153,000 over 30 years at 3.3% fixed gives that €670. But comparing the payment with the rent mixes up two different things. In the first year the payment splits like this, together with the costs that the payment does not show:

Buying today, first year, per monthPer monthComes back?
Interest€417No
Debt repaid€253Yes, it is saving
Maintenance, insurance, extraordinary works€205No
Tax relief on the interest−€63—
What does not come back€559
…plus what the €53,600 of down payment and buying costs would earn elsewhere: €0 at 0%, €89 at 2%, €179 at 4% a year€0–179No

Rent, on the other hand, never comes back: all €950 of it. Measured this way, with these assumptions, buying in Turin today starts from a better position than it did in 2014. That is arithmetic on today's asking prices and an assumed rate, not a forecast: it says nothing about where prices, rents or markets will go.

10. Your numbers

To run the same comparison for yourself you need your own figures, not ours:

Try it with your numbers → The calculator uses the same model as this study: put in your house, your mortgage, your rent and your assumptions, and see who ends up ahead after 10, 20 or 30 years.

The fund used in the simulation, with its prices and distributions, is on its page; the simulator shows what a monthly investment in an income fund would have done.

Method and sources

Not investment advice. Educational content: a simulation on past data with stated assumptions; your city, prices, rates and taxes can change the result. You can lose part of your capital.

Important information. Master of Yield is an independent research tool. All content on this site, including fund data, screeners, scores, model portfolios and backtests, is provided for information and education only. Nothing here is investment, legal, tax or accounting advice, nor a recommendation or solicitation to buy, sell or hold any financial instrument. We are not a broker, a bank or an authorised investment adviser, and we have no knowledge of your personal circumstances. Any investment decision you make is yours alone: consult a qualified adviser before acting.

Our approach. Our model portfolios follow a purely quantitative, rules-based method focused on income. Funds are selected, ranked and rotated by statistical criteria applied mechanically: price erosion since inception, sustainability of distributions, dividend growth, yield and total return. No discretionary judgement or view on individual companies or markets is involved, and the same rules apply to every fund.

About the backtests. Portfolio results are hypothetical simulations run on historical data, not records of real trades or of any real account. Among other simplifications, they assume every fund could be bought and sold at its month-end price with no spread, commission or market impact; they show figures before tax unless you set your own tax profile under "Taxes", where you choose your country and can adjust every rate and the commission your broker charges per trade — those figures are an estimate, not a tax calculation; and they convert every amount to euro at the daily exchange rate. The fund universe only contains products that exist today, so funds that closed in the past are missing, which tends to flatter results. Many funds have short histories, so some results cover only a few years of a largely rising market. Rules may be refined over time and each refinement is applied to the full history, so past results can change. Past or simulated performance does not guarantee future results, and every investment can lose value, including the capital invested.

About the data. Data on HANetf and Leverage Shares (IncomeShares) funds is published with the permission of the issuers; data on the other funds comes from publicly available sources and third-party providers. Data is not independently verified. No warranty is given as to its accuracy, completeness or timeliness. Always check figures with the fund provider before acting. Fund reference data (expense ratio, fund size, domicile) is completed with the EU ETF Universe dataset by Danimoth, used under the CC BY 4.0 licence: danimoth.com/dataset.

Where funds can be offered. Not every fund is registered for distribution in every country. Nothing on this site is an offer of a fund to investors in a country where it is not registered. Where the issuer tells us the countries, the fund page shows them; before investing, check with your broker or the issuer that the fund is available where you live.

Intellectual property. Fund names and trademarks belong to their respective owners. Content from this site may not be reproduced or redistributed without written permission.