Tools

Rent or buy? Calculator

Same money at the start, same budget every month: one person buys with a mortgage, the other rents an equivalent home and invests the rest in a fund. Every month whoever spends less on their home invests the difference. Put in your numbers and see who ends up with more — and what it depends on. The starting values are those of our study on Turin.

1The house and the mortgage
€
%
%
years
%
%
2The rent
€/month
%/yr
years
months
months
3The owner's costs
%/yr
€/year
%/yr
4The future: your assumptions
%/yr
%/yr
%/yr
%
years

After 30 years, selling everything

Buys €505,577

Selling the house, repaying what is left of the mortgage (€0), and selling the fund bought with the monthly difference. Keeping the house instead: €518,246.

Rents and invests €165,272

Selling the fund after tax on the gain, plus the deposit back. Invested on day one: €49,541.

With these assumptions, whoever buys ends up €340,305 ahead. The two end level if the fund returns 10.5% a year: above that, renting and investing finishes ahead; below, buying does.
Buys: house minus mortgage, plus fund Rents: fund plus deposit
0143.19k286.39k429.58k572.78k 202620322038204420502056
0143.19k286.39k429.58k572.78k 202620322038204420502056

Values at the end of each year, before selling: no agency fee and no tax on the gain yet.

The first year, month by month

A mortgage payment of €670 is not the cost of owning: part of it repays the debt, which is saving, and the payment does not show the owner's costs. The house costs about 16.8 years of rent.

Buying, first year, per monthPer monthComes back?
Interest€417No
Debt repaid€253Yes, it is saving
Maintenance, insurance, extraordinary works€207No
Tax relief on the interest-€63—
What does not come back€561
…plus what the €53,550 paid on the day would earn in the fund€223No
Rent€950No

Where the money goes

BuysRents and invests
Paid on the day€53,550€53,550
…of which buying costs / deposit and agency€15,300€2,850 + €1,159
Invested in the fund over the years, as monthly difference€106,932€0
Money that never comes back (interest, owner's costs and buying costs after relief / rent and agency)€188,639€434,429
At the end: house value / fund€346,137€188,292
Fund of the buyer€187,046—
Selling costs and tax€12,669 + €14,937€25,870
Selling everything€505,577€165,272

By then the mortgage is paid off: the home costs the owner about €371 a month, while the rent has reached €1,528.

How it works, and its limits

Not investment advice. Educational tool: a projection with your assumptions, not a forecast. Your city, prices, rates and taxes can change the result. You can lose part of your capital.

Important information. Master of Yield is an independent research tool. All content on this site, including fund data, screeners, scores, model portfolios and backtests, is provided for information and education only. Nothing here is investment, legal, tax or accounting advice, nor a recommendation or solicitation to buy, sell or hold any financial instrument. We are not a broker, a bank or an authorised investment adviser, and we have no knowledge of your personal circumstances. Any investment decision you make is yours alone: consult a qualified adviser before acting.

Our approach. Our model portfolios follow a purely quantitative, rules-based method focused on income. Funds are selected, ranked and rotated by statistical criteria applied mechanically: price erosion since inception, sustainability of distributions, dividend growth, yield and total return. No discretionary judgement or view on individual companies or markets is involved, and the same rules apply to every fund.

About the backtests. Portfolio results are hypothetical simulations run on historical data, not records of real trades or of any real account. Among other simplifications, they assume every fund could be bought and sold at its month-end price with no spread, commission or market impact; they show figures before tax unless you set your own tax profile under "Taxes", where you choose your country and can adjust every rate and the commission your broker charges per trade — those figures are an estimate, not a tax calculation; and they convert every amount to euro at the daily exchange rate. The fund universe only contains products that exist today, so funds that closed in the past are missing, which tends to flatter results. Many funds have short histories, so some results cover only a few years of a largely rising market. Rules may be refined over time and each refinement is applied to the full history, so past results can change. Past or simulated performance does not guarantee future results, and every investment can lose value, including the capital invested.

About the data. Data on HANetf and Leverage Shares (IncomeShares) funds is published with the permission of the issuers; data on the other funds comes from publicly available sources and third-party providers. Data is not independently verified. No warranty is given as to its accuracy, completeness or timeliness. Always check figures with the fund provider before acting. Fund reference data (expense ratio, fund size, domicile) is completed with the EU ETF Universe dataset by Danimoth, used under the CC BY 4.0 licence: danimoth.com/dataset.

Where funds can be offered. Not every fund is registered for distribution in every country. Nothing on this site is an offer of a fund to investors in a country where it is not registered. Where the issuer tells us the countries, the fund page shows them; before investing, check with your broker or the issuer that the fund is available where you live.

Intellectual property. Fund names and trademarks belong to their respective owners. Content from this site may not be reproduced or redistributed without written permission.